The below short story originally appeared in American Crime Magazine.
Black Horse Pike
By Paul Davis
The bartender in a small dark roadside bar on the Black Horse Pike introduced himself to us as Bob as he served my friend Tony and I drinks. He then offered us menus.
We ordered sandwiches and Bob said he was glad we were drinking, as he had been a bartender for forty years and he didn't trust a man who didn't drink.
“No problem here,” Tony told him.
We had taken the old way from South Philadelphia to Atlantic City at the New Jersey shore, which was the way we had gone as teenagers in the 1960s before they built the New Jersey Expressway. We took the old way to Atlantic City as Tony wanted to make a stop at the home of one of his relatives.
We were on our way to Atlantic City to cover the trial of a South Philly mob guy later that week. The notorious mobster had been arrested by the Atlantic City Police at a diner as he was pounding away on a gambler who was behind on his payments.
As the local newspaper's crime columnist, I was going to Atlantic City to cover the trial and Tony, one the local paper’s photographers, accompanied me.
We ordered a second round and Bob again told us of his mistrust of non-drinkers.
“Want to hear a story while you're waiting for your food to come out?”
“Sure,” I replied.
“Well, about fifty years ago a thin man with glasses, a meek-looking guy, kinda shy, came in and sat at one of those tables. Ole Joe, the old bartender then, left the bar and went over to the table to take the man's order. The shy man hardly looked up as he ordered a cheeseburger in a low, hesitant voice.
“The bar was nearly empty except for the shy man and a group of six local boys. Young tough guys and bad boys, you might call ‘em.”
“Want a beer or something to drink with your cheeseburger?” Ole Joe asked the shy man.
“No,” the shy man said softly. “Just a glass of water.”
“Mister,” Ole Joe said, “This is a bar, you know.”
“Your sign outside reads Bar and Grill. I’ll just use the grill part if you don't mind.”
“OK,” Ole Joe said.
The group of young men heard the exchange between the shy man and Ole Joe and they laughed loudly.
One of them yelled out. “Get him a soda pop,” Another yelled out, “Get him a glass of milk.”
The shy man ignored the insults and taunts.
After the shy man had finished his cheeseburger in silence, he got up from the table and went to the bar. He asked the bartender for his check.
“Well, Ole Joe hands him a check for $30 dollars.”
“What's this?” The shy man asked Ole Joe.
“The boys over there said you was picking up their tab too,” Ole Joe said.
The shy man turned slowly towards the group of small-town toughs and then turned back to the bartender. “I never agreed to that,” he said softly.
“Listen,” Ole Joe said quietly, leaning in, “Mister, it might be better to just pay.”
The shy man told Ole Joe to call the police.
“They won’t get here in time and I don't want to see you get hurt or my place smashed up, so just pay up, OK.”
“Do what I said,” the shy man in a soft, calm voice.
“The local boys were all drunk and having fun and they sure was brave in a group of six,” Bob said. “Dummy Number One and Dummy Number Two got up from the table and approached the shy man at the bar.
Hey,” Dummy Number One said. “Why ain’t you paying for our beers and food?”.
“Pay your own bill,” the shy man said softly without turning to face the two young men.
“Now Ole Joe was in the army in World War II and he thought he saw everything,” Bob said. “But when Dummy Number One grabbed the shy man's jacket, Ole Joe saw a blur of arms and as swift as you can imagine, Dummy Number One was on the floor screaming about his broken arm.”
Bob said the shy man also dropped Dummy Number Two to the floor as the rest of the pack charged him.
“It was all so quick that most of the bad boys didn't know what happened,” Bob said. “But they was all on the floor with broken bones or just plain knocked out."
The shy man then said to Ole Joe, “Didn't I tell you to call the police?
“Yes, sir,” Ole Joe said as he picked up the phone.
“Well, it turns out that the man was shy, but not meek. He was some kind of soldier who was in Vietnam and he sure knew how to fight close up and all.”
“It goes to show you,” Tony said. “Don't judge a book by its cover.”
“Yeah,” Bob the bartender replied. “And don't trust a man who don't drink."
Tony and I laughed.
"I ought to know,” Bob said.
“How so?” I asked.
“I was Dummy Number Five.”
© Paul Davis2020